Johnston & Murphy Shoes Review: Quality, Comfortable, and Stylish Shoes

Andrew B. McCutchen

Want to try stylish as well as high-quality shoes for the next purchase? Then sit and let us explore the Johnston & Murphy shoes together to evaluate if it's a great brand with perfect craftsmanship, versatility, and comfort at the peak. Discover this brand's features, styles, and best-selling shoes in-depth.

Men have many problems, and there are classic issues that you can address., if you have planned for a fancy date out, making an outfit is simple, but pairing it with the right shoes becomes a lacking option in your mind. While many brands offer shoes with different and unique styles or designs, not all fall within your budget. There is no need to break the bank when you have options.

Therefore, in our series of reviews, we would like to present the Johnston and Murphy company to you. We would review the company in detail to highlight some of its best-selling shoes for men as well as women and find out if these shoes are quality, comfortable, and stylish. Keep reading right hand and learn from the expert customers online. Although we will review the customers' feedback, the discounts, and the evaluation section, let us start with the basics about the company.

Table Of Contents

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Review

Johnston & Murphy founded in 1850, has been on the market for over 100 years offering shoes making services. The Company has been famous for providing the president and first-class musician outfitting; it has also established a long history among eminent officials. The Company serves men and women, with many stores worldwide targeting to reinvent classic while committed to the products line.

This review will consider the critical elements in deciding your next shoe purchase. William J. Dudley founded Johnston & Murphy, based in Newark. Before the inception of the america war, the Company was previously known as The William J. Dudley Shoes, traced from 1850. With the small effort of the founder, it has grown with a long track record of development and outfitted products.

From the 13th US presidential to the current market, the brand has offered the favored dark suit among the dressers, signing the vibrant products that shed every president. It is clear that Johnston & Murphy has been and is still meeting all the requirements for the US leaders' taste with timeless classics and guaranteed reinventing force that even President Obama used while in power.

The Company transitioned the name in 1886 from the namesake, who was linked to the business partners alongside the company friends in shoemaking. Later, Johnston & Murphy gained more rapport by offering the needs of different folks with various strokes; Ulysses S. Grant chose knee-high riding shoes. Therefore, in the late 19th century, the Company entered the market as a class act.

Many magazines published it as a go-to purchase store with a wide selection of distinctive dresses. Since it has become an iconic brand, it still offers and impresses ladies and men worldwide even though the approach used to establish the women's shoes was inspired by the men;'s style with multiple changes to make them unique to look more feminine.

The Company is famous because they ensure people are well-dressed with timeless styles and designs and commit to offering the classic back into the most stylish form. Thus as a summary, we will consider the pros and cons of this Johnston & Murphy review before moving forward.

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Pros:

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Cons:

Why We Like Johnston & Murphy Shoes

We recommend Johnston & Murphy Shoes to you. Among them is that the company offers you sympathetic shoes based on your budget. Still, the shoes are lightweight but are made to last long and are compatible with flexible feet. They feature cushioned inner soles, which ensure perfect customer experience, performance, and comfort besides being breathable.

Johnston & Murphy Shoes match multiple outfits and make you feel comfortable while you step out into the world. Due to the demands and aim of this review, we would like to move to the best-selling shoes in each category.

The Best-Selling Johnston & Murphy Shoes For Men

There are over 100 laced-up shoes in the inventory, including sandals, dress shoes, boots, sneakers, and slip-ups. The collection is extensive, but in this section, we will only highlight some of the favorite pairs designed for men. The first on the list is Copeland Chukka Boot which has an exciting history inspired by the polo game.

The company has encapsulated the reputation of this old fashion boot which is available in red-brown oiled whole grain as well as black tumbled full grain leather. The shoes also come with the ability to keep your feet soft through their sheepskin lining. They are designed using memory foam cushioning alongside the genuine crepe rubber sole.

Second is Holden Penny Loafer, which became famous over the last 80 years and got inspiration from the slip-ons worn by popular farmers in Norway. The shoes make you become a college boy. The company has coined it through the modern interpretation to feature the shock-absorbing and flexible EVA sole.

The shoes are innovative and combine popular styles along the ultralight to attain comfort. It is made with genuine leather for fitting, while memory foam is vital for cushioning and suitable for daily tasks all day and night.

McGuffey Plain-Toe Oxford is the next popular shoe from the Johnston and Murphy company. These shoes were even known before the brand's inception in the market. Today, the boots come with updated styles as well as textures to bring in more interest.

They are designed using the soft matte nubuck, breathable knit, and oiled full-grain leather. It is made for daily wear even though it features an elevated appearance with a lightweight Strobel and insole covered by the fabric. They are available in multiple colors to select from.

Up next is Melton Cap Toe Oxford. and if you are used to a casual appearance, then this is the time you need to suit up. The shoes are accessible in different colors, tan to black, calfskin, and burgundy. Obama and Roosevelt dressed in these shoes. This is because the shoes feature optimal comfort as well as multilayered cushioning for comfort. Still, the boots are breathable with their perforated leather lining. All these features target to highlight the styles and convenience before the crowd.

Summing up the men's list is Conard Wingtip which the style has been in existence for the last 400 years. It is traced to have originated from the Irish and Scottish. The shoes are perfect for people who want to remain showstoppers or wish to purchase hand-burnished Italian leather shoes. Many customers have praised the versatility of these shoes, which means one can dress down and up with either matching or unique laces to bring out the luxurious comfort due to the cushioned insole and leather lining.

The Best-Selling Jonhston & Murphy Shoes For Women

Before summing up this section, the company has also expanded to offer women's shoes in the store. Thus, we summarize a few features of Johnston and Murphy women's shoes. The section is limited when it comes to womens heels, but you can choose from the 70's styles of flats, heels, mules, sneakers, sandals, and wedges. Thus, some of the favorite and carefully selected best-selling shoes for women start by mentioning Laina Heels, which is the perfect element of surprise for a woman.

The shoes are in store featuring denim kid suede, sand kid suede, and black nappa leather. These trap pumps, as well as featuring modern almond toes, make ladies more comfortable throughout their daily routine. What makes these shoes unique and popular is that they feature sheepskin leather lining and are made with the pilloy foam-cushioned footbed as well as a buckle strap beside the hidden elastic gore.

These shoes are a no-brainer for all ladies and are perfect during summer alongside the dress, which makes it stunning and elegant.

The second in line is Petrina Mules. This name was coined from the Malleus, a Latin word that symbolizes the traditional style meant for ceremonial footwear. These shoes offer the bygone era opulence testament. They are available in silver Italian leopard print as well as white nappa leather and black, not to mention the leopard haircut.

The shoes are made to appear practical, and the company pairs the pragmatic alongside the chick metallic featuring glamorous animal prints to attain the trendy petrina. They are also comfortable due to the cushioned footbed, rubber sole, and leather lining.

The last favorite for ladies here is Julia Sandals. These Johnston & Murphy shoes can put the stylist twist on the flirty traditional look. The shoes come in different colors but have a bit of the lift rubber sole in the cork-wrapped wedge. Since the shoes are seasonal, they are complemented with the leather or floral print insole and leather lining.

Johnston & Murphy are broad, and we would not go through all of them. However, the above sections are best for your starting point without wasting time on the platform chosen from the vast collection.

Customer Review

The Johnston & Murphy Shoes review intended to extend and cover what customers think and their experience using this brand's products. This took us time to explore the feedback from various sites online.

However, we started with their official website At this point, the site has recorded excellent ratings from previous customers. With about 49579 product reviews, customers give the company a rating of 4.5 stars. Many people are completing the high quality, huge collection, guaranteed comfort, and even affordable pricing points. One of the recent customers complimented, saying;-

"Exceptionally knitted shoes of excellent quality." Lightweight and comfy. I want to wear them but don't want them to get dirty. They are bigger. I've always worn a size 11. I purchased a variety of footwear, including leather dress shoes, slip-ons, and knits. I had to reorganize them into 10.5."

Also, The Adult Man site explores the company and analyzes the brand with over 170 years in the field to find out what they have for customers in the store. Based on the design, comfort, quality, value for money, and pricing aspects, the company scores an overall rating of 4 stars. The author praises the high-quality material, comfort, top-notch customer support, and business history. Though the blog also highlights drawbacks, they are not worth attention. In the bottom line, the author concludes:-

"Johnston & Murphy's shoes are designed with the purist at heart." Their softness and longevity outperform comparable mid-range models, although they may lack the support, structure, and finer detail of their higher-priced counterparts."

Next up on the external site is Gentle Man Within. This blog's author explores and cross-examples the Johnson and Murphy shoes considering the class and comfort. Starting from the company's history, the author goes beyond these shoes' comfort and classic nature, including the specification. In the end, he also mentions areas where the company needs to improve, which include the size of the sole, the color balance, and so on.

Other than considering the youtube video, there is also an excellent rating of these Johnson and Murphy men's melton cap toe reviews on Amazon. Out of the 828 global ratings, the shoe gets 4.3 amazing stars, and 74% of the customers gave it a 5 stars rating. Also, Modest Man analyzes the brand closely, considering the style, comfort, price vs. quality, and size.

Business Insider and Zappos conclude the brand in general. Most people online are happy with the brand and praise the pricing, quality, comfort, and many other aspects of one brand. Johnson and Murphy deserve credit for classic shoes for presidential outfits and first-class musicians.

Where to Buy Johnston & Murphy Shoes

To this end, you should not struggle with where to purchase the Johnston & Murphy Shoes and other products. The most reliable place to order is from their official store But still, our review went beyond finding other retail stores online. Therefore, the findings indicate that Johnston & Murphy Shoes are also available in the stores such as:-

Is Johnston & Murphy Shoes Worth It?

This review also dived into the Johnston & Murphy Shoes customer ratings to evaluate its long-standing reputation online. Many online customers have complimented the brand for its legendary quality and exceptional customer support services. If you prefer variety as well as unique styles in the shoe sector, then Johnston & Murphy Shoes is here for you.

These guys ensure you have comfortable footwear at all costs, with a vast collection to select from based on your needs. However, some stores have indicated the overbearing of the employees. The company offers shoes targeting men and women under one roof even though the concern is raised on the inferior quality material but at an affordable price point.

On the website, it is clear that Johnston & Murphy Shoes are exceptional, indicating the innovative nature as we; as the elephant quality alongside the fine details. The brand offers stiff competition to the expensive alternative companies online with their affordable point and trendy and stylish options, which guarantees comfort at its peak. Evaluating the brand, their shoes are worth the money and offer the best for what you pay for.

The company never holds on to the quality of material but instead meets all the standards on earth, looking at its durability and in-store experience while shopping is average. Gove Johnston & Murphy Shoes a try on your next purchase and enjoy discounts, promotions, and affordable pricing for stylish and comfortable shoes for any part of the world.

Johnston & Murphy shoe Discounts

Johnston & Murphy Shoes also come at a discounted price. There are multiple promotions and other lucrative deals from the websites. First, our research can identify the 10% off on the first order when you sign up for the account. Though they offer a free return policy, they also guarantee all customers free shipping when they place an order totaling $50 and above.

Also, the ability for customers to enjoy or try on the item with free risk for 60 days is an excellent move and one of the promotions. On frequent sales, the company offers customers the chance to save up to 40% off, a lifetime offer on the website that covers not only the shoes but also accessories and apparel in the store. You can also access the 20% off as a special offer, but when you purchase two and above products, this does not apply to the large and extra large Flex apparel.

On the men's socks, you can also see that the company goes 20% off when you purchase 3 and above pairs. Still, you can get one free face mask when you buy one. Subscribe to the mailing list for all the latest deals from the website and stay updated.

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Contact

If you have an extra or disturbing inquiry about the Johnston & Murphy shoes, you can direct it to the company's customer support team. We have collected a few contact details on the website, and it's clear that the technical team is readily available to help you. Thus, you can connect with the Johnston & Murphy company through the call at (800) 424 2854.

You can also refer to the contact us section on the official website to fill in the contact form and reach them within no time. However, it would help if you kept in mind that the team is only available from Monday through Friday, from 7 am to 7 pm CST, while on Saturday, they are operational from 9 am to 2 pm. We could also spot the support team active on the social media platform.

Thus, reach out to them on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, etc., anytime and collaborate, ask for clarification, and access all the latest information or updates on the promotions.


Q. What shoe sizing does Johnston & Murphy offer customers?

The review and data on their website showed that the company provides detailed information about shoe sizing and other information. Therefore, due to unavoidable circumstances, we recommend checking out their website for sizing and everything you want.

Q. What is the shipping policy of the Johnston & Murphy brand?

Our review indicates that Johnston & Murphy offers customers a favorable shipping policy. There are multiple shipping services, and to start with, standard shipping is available, where this method delivers orders between 3 to 50 business days. However, when you use the express order, you must place an order between 1 pm CSM From Monday to Thursday for delivery.

But when you place the order after 1 pm, then it means your purchase will be processed the next day. Also, any order processed on Friday is delivered on Monday and Tuesday, but the time depends on your chosen shipping method. Note that the FedEx group does not ship to the P.O. box addresses. Otherwise, the company charges the shipping cost based on the merchandise sum prior to shipping and tax cases.

Also, remember that the brand only offers shipping to the Alaska, Hawaii, FPO, and APO address alongside the continental U.S. states. Thus, any order to be delivered to Alaska as well as Hawaii must be upgraded to use the 2-day or, instead, next-day shipping services. If your order is below 50, group shipping will cost you $4.95 during its free when above the threshold. FedEx's 2-day service charges $12.95 for all orders delivered through the air, while the next-day air also charges a fixed amount of $19.95 for shipping.

Q. What is the return policy of the Johnston & Murphy brand?

The company is working to ensure that customers are satisfied with their products; they are struggling to obtain high-quality shoes and offer comfort at their best. But from our research, we have found that Johnston & Murphy guarantees free return services for either exchange or a full refund.

However, for you to enjoy the exchange and refund option, the merchandise must remain unworn and without any defect, which you have 90 days from the date of purchase. Initiating the return process is simple, But remember there are a few things you must include. The first is the return form and receipt. Then once approved, if it's a refund, you will receive your buck through the original payment method.

Your refund will be less than the tax and other charges involved. Thus initial shipping cost is not refunded alongside the refund money. Any item that you return to the store cannot be returned. You head online and complete the return form for returning via the mail. You must attach the prepaid label and ensure the item is in its original packaging. The service is a, so still available through the approved retail stores.


Suppose you are looking for a loafer, semi-formal, or official shoes for men and women. In that case, Johnston and Murphy's brand is here for you with affordable but comfortable, durable shoes and other accessories. The company has been around for a long time and provides presidential outfittings, styles, high-quality shoes, and other accessories like suites for world-class musicians worldwide.

The above review article shows that the brand guarantees favorable shipping and return policy alongside lucrative deals. If you want to enjoy classic shoes, then Johnston and Murphy is your next-stop shop for an elegant look.

Featured Reviews

407,117 Reviews Analyzed
393,105 Reviews Analyzed
68,464 Reviews Analyzed
94,813 Reviews Analyzed
65,938 Reviews Analyzed
319,883 Reviews Analyzed
51,419 Reviews Analyzed
64,362 Reviews Analyzed
142,844 Reviews Analyzed

Related Posts