Best Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies (April 2024) - Rated by CherryPicks' Experts

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Top 1

Back To Nature Non-Gmo Cookies, Homestyle Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk, 8 Ounce

9.9
CPR Score
Top 2

Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingr...

9.8
CPR Score
Top 3

Back to Nature Non-GMO Cookies, Peanut Butter Creme, 9.6 Ounce

9.6
CPR Score
Tips

We researched and analyzed dozens of Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies reviews from different Breads & Bakery brands, including Lenny & Larry's, Nature Valley, Grandma's, Nutter Butter, Back to Nature, Europe Standard, Pillsbury, Lance, SuperFat, Tribeca Curations, Matt's Bakery, TraderB, Benton's, Scott's Cakes, Real, David's Cookies, Big cookie, Emmy's, Alpino And ALEIAS BEST. TASTE. EVER.. We've selected 29 best Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies in the following ranking by considering price, product features, easy to use and so on.

* Cherrypicksreviews.com is reader-supported, Our editor review, and recommend the best products based on extensive data analysis, if you click on the product links, we may earn a commission through qualifying products purchased.

The Best Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Rated by CherryPicks

Market Overview
Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 151,929 Items
  • CPR Avg. Rating: 8.5 / 10
29 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $99.99
  • Lowest Price: $3.18
  • Avg. Price: $24.50
Price Disclaimer

Top 29 Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies on Amazon (Verified You can Buy)

Back To Nature Non-Gmo Cookies, Homestyle Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk, 8 Ounce

Back to Nature
1150223

Ratings for Back to Nature (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

No hydrogenated fats or high fructose corn syrup allowed in any food
No bleached or bromated flour
Show More

Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients; 4 Bags (10.5oz Each)

Matt's Bakery
0.6563 Pounds

Ratings for Matt's Bakery (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Matt's Cookie Company -

Features

CHEWY, NUTTY & SCRUMPTIOUS - Our peanuts are made the old-fashioned way – Southern peanuts, slow-roasted until they’re perfectly crunchy. Our peanut butter contains two simple ingredients: peanuts and salt.
THE REAL STUFF - We start with all-natural ingredients just like you’d find at home. We have been using real ingredients since the very beginning. Next, we bake the cookies with care in ovens that, for over 30 years, have delivered a perfectly soft texture.
Show More
Top 3

Back to Nature Non-GMO Cookies, Peanut Butter Creme, 9.6 Ounce

Back to Nature
12017p
0.6 Pounds

Ratings for Back to Nature (CPR Score)

Features

Non-GMO Project Verified and Kosher
Enjoy peanut butter creme cookies that taste as if they just left the oven
Show More

Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, 16g Plant-Based Protein per Cookie, Vegan, Non-GMO, 4 Oz (Pack of 12)

Lenny & Larry's

Ratings for Lenny & Larry's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Lebgru -
Eternity Essentials 1,561

Features

Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, 16g Plant-Based Protein per Cookie, Vegan, Non-GMO, 4 Oz (Pack of 12)

Lenny & Larry's Keto Cookie, Peanut Butter, Soft Baked, 9g Plant Protein, 3g Net Carbs, Vegan, Non-GMO, 1.6 Ounce Cookie (Pack of 12)

Lenny & Larry's
55200
8.2 x 5.0 x 4.1 Inches
0.1 Pounds
  • Unknown: German
  • Unknown: Spanish

Ratings for Lenny & Larry's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Lenny & Larry's -
GC - God in Control Store -

Features

Delicious: Chock full of roasted peanuts and creamy peanut butter, our delectable Peanut Butter vegan protein cookie is packed with plant based protein, plenty of fiber, low net carbs and zero guilt
Plant Based Protein and Low Carb: With 3g of net carbs, 9g of plant based proteins, and 5g of fiber this cookie will not only satisfy your tummy and sweet tooth but also your peace of mind
Show More
Top 6

ALPINO Chocolate Peanut Butter Smooth | 19% Protein | Made with Roasted Peanuts, Chocolate Paste, Brown Sugar and Sea Salt | Plant Based Protein Peanut Butter Creamy (14.1 Ounce)

Alpino
CH400
2.9528 x 2.9528 x 4.1339 Inches
0.8813 Pounds

Ratings for Alpino (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
SixxStore -
goGLOCAL -

Features

Delicious Chocolate Peanut Butter, Made with Roasted Peanuts, Chocolate Paste, Brown Sugar and, Sea Salt
The Product is Non-GMO, Gluten-Free and Suitable for Vegan Diet
Show More

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer Cookies, 12 - 10.5 oz packages

Nutter Butter
18.2 x 12.0 x 8.9 Inches
7.875 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies—made with real peanut butter—are the peanut butter lover's cookie.
Nutter Butter Creme Patties have crispy wafers filled with sweet peanut butter cream to satisfy both your savory and sweet snack cravings.
Show More

Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, Family Size, 15.27 oz

Nutter Butter
1.38 x 8.0 x 6.23 Inches
0.95 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Rafa&De -
B&M All Trades -
DRM Fix 9,656
Store sure -
KWarez Goods and Services -
CQSquaredZ -

Features

One 15.27 oz. family size pack of Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Crunchy peanut butter cookies made with real peanut butter for a salty and sweet treat
Show More

Aleia's Gluten Free Foods Cookies, Peanut Butter, Gluten Free, 9-ounce (2 Pack)

ALEIAS BEST. TASTE. EVER.

Ratings for ALEIAS BEST. TASTE. EVER. (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Eternity Essentials 1,561
Goodstuff Stores -

Features

Gluten Free

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies - 1.75 Ounce (Pack of 40)

Lance
0.8375 Pounds

Ratings for Lance (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
ELDENI -
KMY Discounters LLC 5,495
Customer loyalty 5,771
Variety Elite Distributors -
The Federation Group 8,959
The Syndicate's 6,268

Features

Made with real peanut butter
Sandwiched between two crispy, baked cookies
Show More
Top 11

David's Cookies 1lb Peanut Butter Fresh Baked Cookies - Handmade and Gourmet Cookies - Delectable and Made with Premium Ingredients - All Natural and No Added Preservatives Cookie Gift Basket - Great Gift For All Occasions

David's Cookies
1.0 Pounds

Ratings for David's Cookies (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Gift Pack Contains: David’s Cookies Peanut Butter cookie gift tin contains a dozen freshly soft-baked cookies.
Perfect Gift for Holidays & Special Occasions: Our fresh homemade cookies are a perfect gift for friends and family members on birthdays, holidays, or any special occasions.
Show More

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 60)

Grandma's
45091
10.0 Pounds

Ratings for Grandma's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
FoodserviceDirect Inc. 2,712
CSDirectSupply 6,183
PMD Online Logistics 9,779
Beverages For You 5,736

Features

Peanut butter flavor offers sweet taste of creamy peanuts
Great-tasting recipe is baked with love for happiness in every bite
Show More

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies - 33 pks - Total 66 Cookies

Big cookie
0.1563 pounds

Ratings for Big cookie (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
WhyPayMoreOnline 873
BargainDeal4U -
PMD Online Logistics 9,779
CW Supply -

Features

2 cookies per package
33 packages
Show More

Aleia's Gluten-Free Foods Cookies, Peanut Butter, Gluten-Free, 9-ounce (1 Pack)

Ratings for Aleia's Gluten-Free Foods Cookies, Peanut Butter, Gluten-Free, 9-ounce (1 Pack) (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Eternity Essentials 1,561

Benton's Bentons Peanut Butter Filled Cookies - 2 Pack

Benton's

Ratings for Benton's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
3774 East Sales 8,722
Vadajo Corp -
Birdie Boutique - Nest of Deals -
Halal Asian Pantry LLC -

Features

Similar taste to Tagalongs, but available all year long!
2015 Better Homes and Gardens Best New Baked Goods Product
Show More

The Brownie Baker Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | 2 Ounce | 12 Count

Ratings for The Brownie Baker Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | 2 Ounce | 12 Count (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
WhyPayMoreOnline 873

Features

12 count box of 2 ounce The Brownie Baker Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
Individually sealed cookies great for snacking at home or on the go
Show More

Pillsbury Soft Baked Cookies, Peanut Butter with Chocolatey Drizzle, 18 ct

Pillsbury
4.25 x 2.25 x 8.5 Inches
0.5956 Pounds

Ratings for Pillsbury (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE COOKIES: Delicious, soft baked peanut butter cookies with chocolatey drizzle that are ready to eat; Perfect for the pantry, lunch box, or afternoon snack
SOFT BAKED COOKIES: Enjoy your favorite Pillsbury flavors without turning on the oven; All the flavor and goodness you expect from Pillsbury cookie dough in a ready to eat cookie
Show More

Nature Valley Biscuit Sandwiches, Peanut Butter, 1.35 oz, 10 ct

Nature Valley
2.25 x 8.75 x 5.5 Inches
0.8438 Pounds

Ratings for Nature Valley (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

CRISPY BISCUIT SANDWICHES: Wholesome, creamy peanut butter biscuits made with whole grain oats; A must-have for an on-the-go snack or in a lunch box
BREAKFAST AND TEA SNACKS: Easy, wholesome bites for breakfast, snack time or an on-the-go invigorating treat; Perfect for the pantry, lunch box, and hiking trail
Show More

NUTTER BUTTER COOKIE PATTIES PEANUT BUTTER CREME WAFERS 10.5 OZ

Nutter Butter
0.6563 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Blessings Emporium -
Okie Sales Company -
Evies Everything -
MASHER MANAGEMENT LLC -
NEXTGEN E-COM -
Top 20

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies, 69.8 Ounce

Lance
4.3625 Pounds

Ratings for Lance (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Perfect with a glass of milk
Made with real peanut butter
Show More

Trader Joe’s Crispy Crunchy Peanut Butter Cookies 14oz 397g (Two Containers)

TraderB

Ratings for TraderB (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Thunder River Sales -
Alennis -
Sweet Orchids -

Features

Crispy Crunchy Peanut Butter Cookies
14oz/397g per container
Show More

Cookies by Grandma's Value Pack Bundle Curated by Tribeca Curations | 2.5 Ounce | Pack of 30 (Peanut Butter)

Tribeca Curations
4.6875 Pounds

Ratings for Tribeca Curations (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
WhyPayMoreOnline 873

Features

30 Twin Packs of 2.5 Ounce Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies (60 Total Cookies)
Grandma's Homestyle Peanut Butter Big Cookies Have A Soft Texture And A Great Peanut Butter Taste
Show More

SuperFat Cookies Keto Snack Low Carb Food Cookies - Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip 3 Pack - Gluten Free Dessert Sweets with No Sugar Added for Paleo Healthy Diabetic Diets

SuperFat

Ratings for SuperFat (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Eternity Essentials 1,561
SuperFat Keto Snacks -

Features

The ultimate long lasting paleo and keto snack - Great energy source while fasting or following a low carb diet. With plant-based fats, protein, and fiber - a dynamic trifecta to help keep you feeling fuller longer.
Amazing taste and texture - Unlike the competition, we made a point to test our cookies rigorously before release. This translates to a much more "normal" tasting cookie, complete with all the taste and texture you're used to!
Show More

Scott's Cakes Peanut Butter Cookies in a 1 Pound Clear Cello Bag

Scott's Cakes
1.0 Pounds

Ratings for Scott's Cakes (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Scott's Cakes -

Features

Baked Fresh and Shipped the same day.
Made with quality ingredients, rich peanut butter chips, fresh butter, and eggs.
Show More

REAL Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies – Gluten Free Semi Soft Baked Cookies – Dairy Free, Vegan, Kosher, Paleo – Delicious Peanut Butter Cookies (3 Bags with 2 Cookies Each + 1 Free Bonus Bag)

Real
0.0066 Pounds

Ratings for Real (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
REAL Cookies -

Features

THE BEST HEALTHY COOKIE ON EARTH: Made with almond and coconut flours, REAL peanut butter chocolate cookies are sure to satisfy the peanut butter lover in you. Amped up with chocolate chips for a decadent and delicious snack with the perfect texture. 4 Bags of 2 Cookies Each.
100% DELICIOUS, 0% JUNK: Made from the finest ingredients and sweetened with pure Vermont maple syrup (never with refined white sugar or other “stand ins”). Good source of protein and fiber.
Show More

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies (40 ct.) vevo

Europe Standard

Ratings for Europe Standard (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Snackur 8,566
Global Supplies NY 1,140
Stam Sales 731
✔️YOUR ONLINE STORE INC 6,201
Top 27

Scott's Cakes Half-Dipped Peanut Butter Cookies with White Chocolate in a White Gourmet Box

Scott's Cakes

Ratings for Scott's Cakes (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Scott's Cakes -

Features

Approx. 2 Pounds
Packed with bakery wax tissue between each cookie.
Show More
Top 28

Lance Nekot Cookie Sandwiches Real Peanut Butter On-The-Go Packs - 8 PK

Lance
1.64 x 7.02 x 5.23 Inches

Ratings for Lance (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Atlas Apparel 9,699
Good Intentions Inc -

Features

5 Grams Protein
O Trans Fat
Show More

Emmy's Organic Coconut Cookies Variety Pack of 4 Flavors ( Peanut Butter, Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Chip, Dark Cacao ) 6 Ounce

Emmy's
1.0 x 1.0 x 1.0 Inches

Ratings for Emmy's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Nature's Own -
Salty Pelican Mercantile -

Features

Includes Four (4) Variety flavors of Emmy's Organic Coconut Cookies ( Peanut Butter, Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Chip, Dark Cacao ) 6 Ounce
Made with 100% organic ingredients and fair-trade dark chocolate chips, these cookies will surely satisfy your sweet tooth!
Show More

Top 10 Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies - Verified to Buy (Apr. 2024)

Top 10 Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by CherryPicks.

  • Back to Nature
  • Matt's Bakery
  • Lenny & Larry's
  • Alpino
  • Nutter Butter
  • ALEIAS BEST. TASTE. EVER.
  • Lance
  • David's Cookies
  • Grandma's
  • Big cookie

Related Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Guides

For more personalized Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies guides, Check those pages,


Top 10 Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Sellers: CPR Seller Rank List

CPR sellers rank is based on CherryPicks-AI bestselling ranking system that helps us analyze each seller's sales trends. The List of top seller ranks is our in-house data, essential for our product ranking to help you make the right shopping choice.

Rank Name Yearly Feedbacks Avg. Ratings
🥇 Stam Sales 3,875 4.9
🥈 WhyPayMoreOnline 3,463 4.8
🥉 Global Supplies NY 2,932 4.7
4 Eternity Essentials 2,397 4.4
5 FoodserviceDirect Inc. 1,630 4.6
6 KMY Discounters LLC 965 4.9
7 Beverages For You 934 3.1
8 Customer loyalty 930 4.9
9 CSDirectSupply 882 4.4
10 ✔️YOUR ONLINE STORE INC 879 4.9
View or download top Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies seller & rating report
Stam Sales [3875] WhyPayMoreOnline [3463] Global Supplies NY [2932] Eternity Essentials [2397] FoodserviceDirect Inc. [1630] KMY Discounters LLC [965] Beverages For You [934] Customer loyalty [930] CSDirectSupply [882] ✔️YOUR ONLINE STORE INC [879] Stam Sales 21% WhyPayMoreOnline 18% Global Supplies NY 16% Eternity Essentials 13% FoodserviceDirect Inc. 9% KMY Discounters LLC 5% Beverages For You 5% Customer loyalty 5% CSDirectSupply 5% ✔️YOUR ONLINE STORE INC 5%

[Get] Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Deals (✅Exclusively for Prime)

What does "Amazon Fulfilled" Mean?

Amazon Fulfilled refers to products handled by Amazon's logistics, which indicates that the product is stored, packed, and shipped by Amazon from one of its fulfillment centers.

When you order a product that is "Amazon Fulfilled," Amazon takes care of the storage, packing, shipping, and customer service for that product. This often ensures quicker delivery and better customer service compared to products that are not fulfilled by Amazon. It also means that the product is eligible for Amazon's return policy.

What does "Prime" Mean?

"Prime" refers to Amazon Prime Member (Join Amazon Prime Now), which indicates eligibility for Prime benefits. When you see "Prime" next to a product on Amazon, This generally means that if you are  an Amazon Prime member, you can get free two-day shipping on that product, and sometimes even same-day or one-day shipping depending on your location.

Prime members also have access to other benefits, including 2-Day ShippingExclusive Member DealsPrime VideoBuy With PrimeAmazon MusicPrime Gaming, and more.

Shop Prime Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies Deals

What does "Free Shipping" Mean?

"Free Shipping" means that you will not be charged additional fees for the shipping of that product. However, unlike "Prime," which usually guarantees fast two-day shipping, "Free Shipping" doesn't necessarily mean fast shipping.

Sometimes there might be a minimum purchase requirement to qualify for free shipping if you are not a Prime member. For Prime members, the "Free Shipping" usually refers to the free two-day shipping that is one of the benefits of the Prime membership.


Why Should You Trust Us?

Now hundreds and thousands of Breads & Bakery supplies are available on Amazon, Picking the right one is not easy, and that may take a lot of your time, Right? and What is the best Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies to buy for new April 2024?

CherryPicks’s Methodology for Evaluating Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies

We developed the CherryRatings-AI system to identify and score reviews and the CherryPicks-AI ranking system that uses TensorFlow framework to generate the best list, It will help us evaluate Breads & Bakery items that sell on Amazon. The score of items is based on over ten parameters such as analyzing customer review content, product reviewing rating statistics, brand reputation evaluation, comparing product price with features, etc, You can visit How We Rank to learn more in detail.

We collected and analyzed 37 of Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies reviews based on our selection criteria. It helped us shortlist the top qualified and rated Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies for Breads & Bakery, We found that most customers choose Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies with an average price of $24.50, and the top brands are Lenny & Larry's, Nature Valley, Grandma's, Nutter Butter, Back to Nature, Europe Standard, Pillsbury, Lance, SuperFat, Tribeca Curations, Matt's Bakery, TraderB, Benton's, Scott's Cakes, Real, David's Cookies, Big cookie, Emmy's, Alpino And ALEIAS BEST. TASTE. EVER.. 

Then our expert-level editors reviewed all those quality items and selected the top 29 Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies for you, We have researched hundreds of sellers and picked the top sellers for Breads & Bakery, including Stam Sales, WhyPayMoreOnline, Global Supplies NY, Eternity Essentials, FoodserviceDirect Inc., KMY Discounters LLC, Beverages For You, Customer loyalty, CSDirectSupply, ✔️YOUR ONLINE STORE INC, The Syndicate's And Snackur. The Back To Nature Non-Gmo Cookies, Homestyle Peanu... are available for purchase right now, and The seller of #1 rank product has received honest feedback from 285 consumers with an average rating of 4.1.

We've helped a lot of satisfied users get the right Grocery & Gourmet Food product based on their needs, and save lots of time for them to pick Non-GMO Peanut-Butter Cookies to buy.


Written By Yesenia D. Garner

Yesenia has a thing for groceries and gourmet foods and with her, you can discover a lot about groceries you didn't know of before. Yesenia pays attention to details and can be termed as a perfectionist to the core. She writes on groceries and food in general here.