Best Peanut-Butter Cookies (Aug. 2022) - Rated by CherryPicks' Experts

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Top 1

Pillsbury Soft Baked Cookies, Peanut Butter with Chocolatey Drizzle, 18 ct

9.8
CPR Score
Top 2

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 60)

9.8
CPR Score
Top 3

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 4 Boxes of 12 Packs (4 Cookies ...

9.7
CPR Score
Tips

We researched and analyzed dozens of Peanut-Butter Cookies products from different Breads & Bakery brands, including Lenny & Larry's, NABISCO, Nature Valley, Grandma's, Nutter Butter, Pillsbury, Fudge Shoppe (Keebler), Lance, Europe Standard, Girl Scouts, Girl Scout Cookies, Matt's Bakery, Big cookie, NUTTER BUTTER At The Neighborhood Corner Store, Little Brownie Baker And Better and Delicious. We've selected 30 best Peanut-Butter Cookies in the following ranking by considering price, product features, easy to use and so on.

* Cherrypicksreviews.com is reader-supported, Our editor review, and recommend the best products based on extensive data analysis, if you click on the product links, we may earn a commission through qualifying products purchased.

The Best Peanut-Butter Cookies Rated by CherryPicks

Show More

Top 30 Peanut-Butter Cookies on Aamazon (Verified You can Buy)

Top 1

Pillsbury Soft Baked Cookies, Peanut Butter with Chocolatey Drizzle, 18 ct

Pillsbury
4.25 x 2.25 x 8.5 inches
0.5956 pounds

Ratings for Pillsbury (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE COOKIES: Delicious, soft baked peanut butter cookies with chocolatey drizzle that are ready to eat; Perfect for the pantry, lunch box, or afternoon snack
SOFT BAKED COOKIES: Enjoy your favorite Pillsbury flavors without turning on the oven; All the flavor and goodness you expect from Pillsbury cookie dough in a ready to eat cookie
Show More
Top 2

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 60)

Grandma's
45091
10.93 pounds

Ratings for Grandma's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
FoodserviceDirect Inc. 1,763
CSDirectSupply 5,902
PMD Online Logistics 6,589

Features

Peanut butter flavor offers sweet taste of creamy peanuts
Great-tasting recipe is baked with love for happiness in every bite
Show More
Top 3

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 4 Boxes of 12 Packs (4 Cookies Per Pack)

Nutter Butter
10044000037458
1.4019 pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Four boxes with 12 snack packs each (4 cookies per pack), 48 total packs, of Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Peanut butter cookies made with real peanut butter for a salty and sweet treat
Show More
Top 4

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies - 40 ct.

Lance
0.8375 pounds

Ratings for Lance (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
KMY Discounters LLC 4,683
Customer loyalty 4,132
The Syndicate's 5,651

Features

Made with real peanut butter
Sandwiched between two crispy, baked cookies
Show More
Top 5

Nutter Butter Bites Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies - Go-Pak, 3.5 Ounce (Pack of 12)

Nutter Butter
004400004457
0.2188 pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Nutter Butter Bites Mini Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies—made with real peanut butter—are the peanut butter lover's cookie.
These crunchy bite-sized peanut butter sandwich cookies are filled with sweet peanut butter cream to satisfy both your savory and sweet-snack cravings.
Show More
Top 6

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer Cookies, 12 - 10.5 oz packages

Nutter Butter
18.2 x 12.0 x 8.9 inches
0.6563 pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies—made with real peanut butter—are the peanut butter lover's cookie.
Nutter Butter Creme Patties have crispy wafers filled with sweet peanut butter cream to satisfy both your savory and sweet snack cravings.
Show More
Top 7

Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients; 4 Bags (10.5oz Each)

Matt's Bakery

Ratings for Matt's Bakery (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Matt's Cookie Company -

Features

CHEWY, NUTTY & SCRUMPTIOUS - Our peanuts are made the old-fashioned way – Southern peanuts, slow-roasted until they’re perfectly crunchy. Our peanut butter contains two simple ingredients: peanuts and salt.
THE REAL STUFF - We start with all-natural ingredients just like you’d find at home. We have been using real ingredients since the very beginning.
Show More
Top 8

Nature Valley Biscuit Sandwiches, Peanut Butter, 1.35 oz, 10 ct

Nature Valley
2.25 x 8.75 x 5.5 Inches
0.8438 Pounds

Ratings for Nature Valley (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

CRISPY BISCUIT SANDWICHES: Wholesome, creamy peanut butter biscuits made with whole grain oats; A must-have for an on-the-go snack or in a lunch box
BREAKFAST AND TEA SNACKS: Easy, wholesome bites for breakfast, snack time or an on-the-go invigorating treat; Perfect for the pantry, lunch box, and hiking trail
Show More
Top 9

Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, Family Size, 15.27 oz

Nutter Butter
1.38 x 8.0 x 6.23 Inches
0.95 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Rafa&De -
B&M All Trades -
Store sure -

Features

One 15.27 oz. family size pack of Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Crunchy peanut butter cookies made with real peanut butter for a salty and sweet treat
Show More
Top 10

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies - 33 pks - Total 66 Cookies

Big cookie
0.1563 Pounds

Ratings for Big cookie (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
WhyPayMoreOnline 1,005
BargainDeal4U -
PMD Online Logistics 6,589

Features

2 cookies per package
33 packages
Show More
Top 11

Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, Family Size, 12 - 15.27 oz Packs

Nutter Butter
16.189 x 8.811 x 7.0 Inches
12.68 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Twelve 15.27 oz. family size packs of Nutter Butter Double Nutty Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Crunchy peanut butter cookies made with real peanut butter for a salty and sweet treat
Show More
Top 12

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies, King Size, 10 – 3.5oz Packs

Nutter Butter
2.075 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
CSDirectSupply 5,902

Features

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies—made with real peanut butter—are the peanut butter lover's cookie.
These crunchy peanut butter sandwich cookies are filled with sweet peanut butter cream to satisfy both your savory and sweet-snack cravings.
Show More
Top 13

Nature Valley Biscuit Sandwiches, Peanut Butter, 1.35 oz, 5 ct

Nature Valley
2.75 x 5.0 x 5.31 Inches
0.4219 Pounds

Ratings for Nature Valley (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Selling Supplies 375
AAX products -
JSR Partners -

Features

CRISPY BISCUIT SANDWICHES: Wholesome, creamy peanut butter biscuits made with whole grain oats; a must-have for an on-the-go snack or in a lunch box
BREAKFAST AND TEA SNACKS: Easy, wholesome bites for breakfast, snack time or an on-the-go invigorating treat; perfect for the pantry, lunch box, and hiking trail
Show More
Top 14

Nutter Butter Fudge Covered Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 7.9 oz

Nutter Butter
2.0 x 7.31 x 4.19 Inches
0.49 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Your Lifestyle Merchant -
Amazed Forever -
The Letter O 7 -

Features

7.9 oz box of Nutter Butter Fudge Covered Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies (packaging may vary)
Enjoy the combo of crispy wafer cookies, smooth peanut butter creme, and rich chocolate fudge. Whether it’s dressed in fudge or au naturel, the Nutter Butter is the peanut butter–lovers’ cookie!
Show More
Top 15

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies (40 ct.) vevo

Europe Standard

Ratings for Europe Standard (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Snackur 5,424
✔️YOUR ONLINE STORE INC -
Top 16

NABISCO NUTTER BUTTER Peanut Sandwich Cookies, 4 Count, Pack of 12

Nutter Butter
00044000088453
9.72 x 9.92 x 9.63 Inches
0.1188 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Up-Time Tech -
B&M All Trades -
The couple -

Features

One box with 12 snack packs (4 cookies per pack) of Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Peanut butter cookies made with real peanut butter for a salty and sweet treat
Show More
Top 17

Girl Scouts Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies

Girl Scout Cookies
0.5 Pounds

Ratings for Girl Scout Cookies (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Green Life store -
3M DIRECT SALES -
picker trading -

Features

2018 Girl Scout Cookies
Top 18

Nutter Butter Bites Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 12 - 3 oz Big Bags

Nutter Butter
0.1875 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Genbeth 9,110

Features

Nutter Butter Bites Mini Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies—made with real peanut butter—are the peanut butter lover's cookie.
These crunchy bite-sized peanut butter sandwich cookies are filled with sweet peanut butter cream to satisfy both your savory and sweet-snack cravings.
Show More
Top 19

Fudge Shoppe (Keebler) Peanut Butter Dreams Cookies, Nuts, 8 Oz

Fudge Shoppe (Keebler)
3010010801
0.5 Pounds

Ratings for Fudge Shoppe (Keebler) (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Vitozon 1,373
The Chosen Shop -

Features

Indulgent cookie rings with the irresistible taste of creamy JIF peanut butter, crunchy peanuts, and delicious fudge flavored coating in every decadent bite; They're uncommonly good
Indulgent cookies fresh from the hollow tree; Perfect for a sweet treat at school, the office, and game time; there's fun in every bite
Show More
Top 20

NUTTER BUTTER COOKIE PATTIES PEANUT BUTTER CREME WAFERS 10.5 OZ

NUTTER BUTTER At The Neighborhood Corner Store
0.6563 Pounds

Ratings for NUTTER BUTTER At The Neighborhood Corner Store (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Okie Sales Company -
Evies Everything -
NEXTGEN E-COM -
Top 21

Nutter Butter Chocolate Fudge Cookies, 12 - 7.9 ounce Packages

Nutter Butter
13.44 x 7.87 x 8.75 Inches
7.578 Pounds

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
DMJ Sales LLC -
Ledesma-AD -

Features

The peanut butter lover's cookie now covered in delicious chocolate fudge
Classic Nutter Butter cookie covered in delicious, rich chocolate fudge
Show More
Top 22

Nabisco Nutter Butter Cookies - 1.9 Oz. - 24 Pks. - SCS

Nutter Butter

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Genbeth 9,110
Abels Corner -
The Coalition 4,621
Variety Elite Distributors -

Features

24/1.9 oz. packs
Made with real peanut butter
Top 23

Girl Scout Peanut Butter Patties Cookies (6.5 Ounce Box)

Girl Scouts
7.2992 x 4.2992 x 2.2992 Inches

Ratings for Girl Scouts (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Green Life store -
Carnavon Co L.L.C. -

Features

Crispy vanilla cookies layered with peanut butter and covered with a chocolaty coating
One 6.5 oz box (14 cookies)
Top 24

B.A.D. FOOD CO The Peanutter - Peanut Butter Cookies | 5.4oz – 6 Pack | , Grain-Free, Gluten-Free, Refined Sugar Free, No-Soy, Dairy-Free, Non-GMO, Paleo Friendly, and Nutrient Dense!

Better and Delicious

Ratings for Better and Delicious (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Nourishing Foods -
B.A.D. FOOD CO. -

Features

BETTER AND DELICIOUS - NUT like your average peanut butter cookie. These grain-free bad boys are made from blanched almond flour, peanut butter, organic coconut sugar and a touch of vanilla. Nutrient dense and high in protein, this is one satisfying cookie. Perfect for snacking or sharing (if you haven’t eaten them all first).
REAL FOOD FOR REAL PEOPLE - We ensure nothing artificial or refined ever darkens our doors. We are stubbornly dedicated to being better and delicious, guaranteeing that our food always makes you feel Heck Yeah!
Show More
Top 25

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 4.8 oz

NABISCO
00044000035518
2.17 x 8.06 x 2.63 Inches
4.8 ounces

Ratings for NABISCO (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Super Savings Now 4,477
Grab Deals -
Continuum_Sales -

Features

Made with real peanut butter from Planter's peanuts; Kosher certified
Cholesterol-free; low in saturated fats; 2 grams of protein and 4% RDA of iron per serving
Show More
Top 26

Nabisco Chewy Chips Ahoy Cookies Reese's Peanut Butter Cup 9.5 oz (4)

0.5938 Pounds

Ratings for Nabisco Chewy Chips Ahoy Cookies Reese's Peanut Butter Cup 9.5 oz (4) (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
WOW Distribution Inc. -
Proverbs 30: 8-9 -
Great Spirit Wares -

Features

As Pictured, choose pack variation wisely
Limited Edition
Show More
Top 27

Girl Scout Cookies Tagalongs Delicious Peanut Butter Patties - 2 Boxes of 15 Cookies

Little Brownie Baker

Ratings for Little Brownie Baker (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Green Life store -
Crazy Soda Pop -

Features

Approx: 15 cookies per box
Top 28

Lenny & Larry's Keto Cookie, Peanut Butter, Soft Baked, 9g Plant Protein, 3g Net Carbs, Vegan, Non-GMO, 1.6 Ounce Cookie (Pack of 12)

Lenny & Larry's
55200
8.2 x 5.0 x 4.1 Inches
0.1 Pounds
  • Unknown: German
  • Unknown: Spanish

Ratings for Lenny & Larry's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Peanut Butter Keto Cookie: A tasty cookie with low net carbs and packed with plant based protein to keep your macros on track. Finally, you can finish a whole box of cookies without feeling guilty
Delicious: Chock full of roasted peanuts and creamy peanut butter, our delectable Peanut Butter vegan protein cookie is packed with plant based protein, plenty of fiber, low net carbs and zero guilt
Show More
Top 29

Grandmas Homestyle Peanut Butter Big Cookies 82.5oz - 33 Pks - Total 66 Cookies by Grandma's

Grandma's

Ratings for Grandma's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
BargainDeal4U -
Top 30

Nutter Butter Family Size Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 4 - 16 oz Packs

Nutter Butter
10044000046313
17.0 x 8.8 x 7.4 Inches
192.0 ounces

Ratings for Nutter Butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
RocketDSD 9,401
Speedy sale co 9,865

Features

Twelve 16 oz packages of Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Peanut butter cookies made with real peanut butter for a salty and sweet treat
Show More

What Should You Consider When Buying Peanut-Butter Cookies?

Peanut butter cookies are a popular American cookie that is usually shaped into a sandwich with two chocolate cookies. There are many different variations of the peanut butter cookie, but the most common way to make them is by combining peanut butter and sugar, then adding eggs and vanilla extract. The dough is rolled out into a flat sheet and then cut into shapes before being baked.

Who invented peanut-butter cookies?

The first documented recipe for peanut butter cookies was published in the 1890s.

In the 1890s, a recipe for peanut butter cookies was published in a Boston cooking magazine called "The American Cookery." The recipe was written by Mrs. A.L. Webster, and it called for baking the cookies on an ungreased pan and for using only one cup of sugar.

What should you look for in a peanut butter cookie?

This is a list of features that you should look for in a peanut butter cookie.

Some people like their cookies to be soft and chewy, others like them to be crispy. Some prefer a thin, crisp cookie while others want theirs thick and fluffy.

The texture of the cookie is one of the most important features to consider when choosing a peanut butter cookie flavor. Texture can vary from crunchy to chewy, depending on how long it's baked, which can make all the difference in your experience with this treatment.

What is the best peanut butter cookie?

This is a question that has been debated for decades. There are many different opinions and some people have strong feelings about which cookie is the best. But there is no clear answer because they all have their own unique taste and texture. It really depends on what you like!

Some people like cookies with a crunchy outside, while others prefer a softer cookie. Some people prefer chocolate chips, while others want to avoid them at all costs. Some people like peanut butter cookies that are thin and crispy, while others want them thick and chewy. The best cookie for you might not be the best for someone else.

How many calories are in a serving of peanut butter cookies?

The answer to this question depends on the size of the cookie. For example, if a cookie is 3 inches in diameter, then it will have about 150 calories. If it is 4 inches in diameter, then it will have about 200 calories. This section contains information about what the average person should know before they eat a serving of peanut butter cookies.

What is the best way to store peanut butter cookies?

The best way to store peanut butter cookies is in a jar with a tight lid. This will help keep them fresh and delicious for as long as possible.

What happens if you don't flatten peanut butter cookies?

Flattening the dough for peanut butter cookies is important to ensure that they are uniform in shape. This ensures that they bake evenly and taste great. If you don't flatten the dough, it will not spread evenly during baking. This will result in a cookie with a thicker center and thinner edges.


Top 10 Peanut-Butter Cookies Sellers: CPR Seller Rank List

CPR sellers rank is based on CherryPicks-AI bestselling ranking system that helps us analyze each seller's sales trends. The List of top seller ranks is our in-house data, essential for our product ranking to help you make the right shopping choice.

Rank Name Yearly Feedbacks Avg. Ratings
🥇 Selling Supplies 5,248 4.9
🥈 WhyPayMoreOnline 2,916 4.8
🥉 Vitozon 2,370 4.6
4 FoodserviceDirect Inc. 2,027 4.6
5 Customer loyalty 1,084 4.8
6 Super Savings Now 1,007 4.9
7 The Coalition 992 4.9
8 KMY Discounters LLC 983 4.9
9 Snackur 837 4.9
10 The Syndicate's 832 4.8
View or download top Peanut-Butter Cookies seller & rating report
Selling Supplies [5248] WhyPayMoreOnline [2916] Vitozon [2370] FoodserviceDirect Inc. [2027] Customer loyalty [1084] Super Savings Now [1007] The Coalition [992] KMY Discounters LLC [983] Snackur [837] The Syndicate's [832] Selling Supplies 29% WhyPayMoreOnline 16% Vitozon 13% FoodserviceDirect Inc. 11% Customer loyalty 6% Super Savings Now 6% The Coalition 5% KMY Discounters LLC 5% Snackur 5% The Syndicate's 5%

Why Should You Trust Us?

Now hundreds and thousands of Breads & Bakery supplies are available on Amazon, Picking the right one is not easy, and that may take a lot of your time, Right? and What is the best Peanut-Butter Cookies to buy in 2022?

CherryPicks’s Methodology for Evaluating Peanut-Butter Cookies

We developed the CherryRatings-AI system to identify and score reviews and the CherryPicks-AI ranking system that uses TensorFlow framework to generate the best list, It will help us evaluate Breads & Bakery items that sell on Amazon. The score of items is based on over ten parameters such as analyzing customer review content, product reviewing rating statistics, brand reputation evaluation, comparing product price with features, etc, You can visit How We Rank to learn more in detail.

We collected and analyzed 162 of Peanut-Butter Cookies products based on our selection criteria. It helped us shortlist the top qualified and rated Peanut-Butter Cookies for Breads & Bakery, We found that most customers choose Peanut-Butter Cookies with an average price of $23.88, and the top brands are Lenny & Larry's, NABISCO, Nature Valley, Grandma's, Nutter Butter, Pillsbury, Fudge Shoppe (Keebler), Lance, Europe Standard, Girl Scouts, Girl Scout Cookies, Matt's Bakery, Big cookie, NUTTER BUTTER At The Neighborhood Corner Store, Little Brownie Baker And Better and Delicious. 

Then our expert-level editors reviewed all those quality items and selected the top 30 Peanut-Butter Cookies for you, We have researched hundreds of sellers and picked the top sellers for Breads & Bakery, including Selling Supplies, WhyPayMoreOnline, Vitozon, FoodserviceDirect Inc., Customer loyalty, Super Savings Now, The Coalition, KMY Discounters LLC, Snackur, The Syndicate's, CSDirectSupply And PMD Online Logistics. The Pillsbury Soft Baked Cookies, Peanut Butter wit... are available for purchase right now, and The seller of #1 rank product has received honest feedback from 6,225 consumers with an average rating of 3.6.

We've helped a lot of satisfied users get the right Grocery & Gourmet Food product based on their needs, and save lots of time for them to pick Peanut-Butter Cookies to buy.


Written By Joyce C. Foster

Joyce is an editor with us here at CherryPicksReviews. She is an exceptional writer, committed to producing the best content on groceries, and ready to taste some any day anytime. She has got years of experience writing with a popular food blog as a food blogger before joining us here.