Best Creamy Peanut Butter (March 2024) - Rated by CherryPicks' Experts

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Top 1

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 Ounces (Pack of 4)

9.9
CPR Score
Top 2

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 48 Ounce, 2 count by Jif

9.7
CPR Score
Top 3

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

9.6
CPR Score
Tips


Our team has analyzed 683 products of different Pantry Staples brands, including Happy Belly, Kirkland Signature, Reese's, SKIPPY, Jif, Peter Pan, Crazy Richard's, Tribeca Curations, Peanut Butter Americano, Once Again, Kroger, Smucker's, Skippy Creamy, Justin's, Good Good, butter And Adam's. The following list of top 30 Creamy Peanut Butter is prepared for the customers by analyzing 683 Creamy Peanut Butter reviews and comparing different features. 

* Cherrypicksreviews.com is reader-supported, Our editor review, and recommend the best products based on extensive data analysis, if you click on the product links, we may earn a commission through qualifying products purchased.

The Best Creamy Peanut Butter Rated by CherryPicks

Market Overview
Creamy Peanut Butter Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 142,724 Items
  • CPR Avg. Rating: 8.5 / 10
30 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $55.00
  • Lowest Price: $2.39
  • Avg. Price: $16.38
Price Disclaimer

Top 30 Creamy Peanut Butter on Amazon (Verified You can Buy)

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 Ounces (Pack of 4)

Jif
051500245385
10.0 Pounds

Ratings for Jif (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Contains 4- 40 Ounce Jars of Jif Creamy Peanut Butter
A gluten-free peanut butter that has 9g protein (9% DV) per serving (See Nutrition Information For Fat And Saturated Fat Content)
Show More

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 48 Ounce, 2 count by Jif

Jif
3.0 Pounds

Ratings for Jif (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Apparel, Accessories, Supplies & more -
jh distribution -
Baileys Bargain Barn -

Features

Gluten-free peanut butter with 7 g protein (7% DV) per serving

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

Jif
051500255162
2.9 x 2.9 x 5.01 Inches
1.0 Pounds
  • Ingredients, Unknown: English

Ratings for Jif (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Franklin Square Pharmacy -
Lilian and Lizzie’s shop -
AJJ Godoy’s -
XPW Enterprise LLC -
Leyden Gen Store -

Features

Contains 1 (one)- 16 Ounce Jars of Jif Creamy Peanut Butter
A gluten-free peanut butter that has 7g protein (7% DV) per serving*
Show More

JUSTIN'S Classic No Stir Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Spread, 28 Ounce Jar

Justin's
0084037910139
3.52 x 3.52 x 5.47 Inches
1.75 Pounds

Ratings for Justin's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Includes one 28-Ounce Classic Peanut Butter Spread Jar, made with only two ingredients using a proprietary nut grinding method to deliver incredible texture and taste. Try it on crackers, in sandwiches, in baking and cooking, with apples or celery or just enjoy a spoonful. Family size jar!
Made with only two ingredients, including only Orangutan-friendly palm oil, Certified Gluten-Free, Vegan, Non-GMO Project Verified, Kosher
Show More

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter, 16.3 Ounce (Pack of 8)

SKIPPY
SVQQPE
0.3937 x 0.3937 x 0.5 Inches
8.15 Pounds

Ratings for SKIPPY (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Spread on the smiles with tasty, creamy peanut buttery perfection. It’s nothing but great snacking with this creamy classic.
Real Roasted Peanuts: This gluten free, certified kosher, tree nut free peanut butter is made with real roasted peanuts and no added preservatives. It spreads easily with no separation and no oily mess.
Show More

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter, 5 Pound

SKIPPY
23432
5.73 x 5.73 x 6.19 Inches
5.0 Pounds

Ratings for SKIPPY (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Creamy Peanut Butter: Spread on the smiles with tasty, creamy peanut buttery perfection. Add more yum and fun to just about anything. It’s nothing but great snacking with this creamy classic
Real Roasted Peanuts: This gluten free, certified kosher, tree nut free peanut butter is made with real roasted peanuts and no added preservatives. It spreads easily with no separation and no oily mess
Show More
Top 7

Jif Simply Creamy Peanut Butter, 15.5 oz, 3 Pack

Smucker's
bundle-5150025527
15.5 ounces

Ratings for Smucker's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Market global 218
Blessings Emporium -
Affordable OTC 2,916

Features

Item Package Dimension: 6.86cm L x 12.95cm W x 21.84cm H
Item Package Weight: 2.9 lb
Show More

Americano Peanut Butter Creamy, Choco Blanco Natural Peanut Butter, 15 Ounce, Low Sugar Peanut Butter Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Natural Peanut Butter Low Sugar Peanut Butter (1 Jar (Pack of 2))

Peanut Butter Americano

Ratings for Peanut Butter Americano (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Americano Foods -

Features

🥜 TAKE CARE OF YOUR DIET: We believe that happiness begins with your nutrition, that’s why we are on a mission to spread more happiness through delicious and nutritious peanut butter. Choco Blanco is the perfect solution for a sweet tooth craving, but with 4x less sugar than traditional chocolate spreads. Our creamy flavorful Choco Blanco has 4g of sugar and 8g of protein per serving.
🥜 MAKE A HEALTHY SNACKING CHOICE:If your kid is a hard nut to crack and you are having a hard time convincing them to choose the right snack, then you don’t have to sacrifice taste for nutritional value. Drizzle this creamy peanut butter over celery, apples, bananas or strawberries to get your daily serving of both fruit and protein.
Show More

SKIPPY Natural Peanut Butter Spread, Creamy, 7 g protein per serving, 40 oz.

SKIPPY
10451
15.88 x 8.06 x 6.56 Inches
2.5 pounds

Ratings for SKIPPY (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Shoppers Unleashed 5,281

Features

One 40 oz. jars of SKIPPY Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread. It’s all-natural: four simple ingredients combine for a sweet and savory peanut flavor and just seven grams of protein and zero grams trans-fat per serving
When combined with nutritious foods like whole grain bread, fruit and milk, helps restore energy and leaves you feeling charged - nothing but great snacking with this creamy classic
Show More

Peter Pan, Peanut Butter, Creamy, 28oz Jar (Pack of 3)

Peter Pan

Ratings for Peter Pan (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Aserson 202
yourfavouritestore -
Super Cyber Savings -

Features

CREAMY
3 28oz plastic jars
Show More

Peter Pan Peanut Butter Creamy 16.3 oz.

Peter Pan
10000177
2.8 x 2.75 x 4.85 Inches
1.02 Pounds

Ratings for Peter Pan (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Common Cents Distributors 85
Woody's World 9,896
SimplyDeliver Inc -

Features

PETER PAN CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER
16.3OZ CONTAINER
Show More

Crazy Richard's 100% All-Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, No Added Sugar Peanut Butter Non-GMO, Vegan (26 Ounce)

Crazy Richard's
3.54 x 3.54 x 5.46 Inches
1.625 Pounds

Ratings for Crazy Richard's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Sebago Foods 112
Mixt Solutions 3,356

Features

Your Healthy Peanut Butter – Indulge in our gluten-free, no salt, no sugar added nut butter. This vegan butter spread is also kosher, bpa-free, and non-gmo.
Made Only with the Best-Tasting Raw Peanuts – There are 540 kinds of raw peanuts in each nut butter jar. We naturally processed these Us-grown ground nuts to perfection.
Show More
Top 13

Tribeca Curations | Family Size Creamy Peanut Butter In A Tin Value Pack | 4 Pound Can | Pack of 2 Includes Tribeca Mints

Tribeca Curations

Ratings for Tribeca Curations (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Market global 218
WhyPayMoreOnline 873

Features

This bundle of JIF products is bought to you by Tribeca Curations. We are an independent curator of variety packs and bundles. We bring you the brands you love in a convenient and economical package. We work tirelessly to bring new offers made to provide value and convenience. Quality assurance and customer satisfaction is our highest priority.
2 Cans Of 4 Pound Creamy Peanut Butter and Tribeca Mints! The best mints out there to cleanse the palate!
Show More

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 Ounce

Happy Belly
6.567 x 3.862 x 6.567 Inches
2.658 Pounds

Ratings for Happy Belly (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

One 40-ounce jar of creamy peanut butter
Packaging might vary
Show More

SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 Ounce Twin Pack,2.5 Pound (Pack of 2)

SKIPPY
10753
0.3937 x 0.3937 x 0.5 Inches
5.0 Pounds

Ratings for SKIPPY (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Ace General Store -

Features

Creamy Peanut Butter: Spread on the smiles with tasty, creamy peanut buttery perfection. Add more yum and fun to just about anything. It’s nothing but great snacking with this creamy classic
Real Roasted Peanuts: This gluten free, certified kosher, tree nut free peanut butter is made with real roasted peanuts and no added preservatives. It spreads easily with no separation and no oily mess
Show More
Top 16

Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, 16 Ounces, Contains 90% Peanuts

Jif
5150025565
2.9 x 2.9 x 4.85 Inches
1.0 pounds

Ratings for Jif (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Premier Prime Outlet -
Affordable OTC 2,916
StyleSack -

Features

Contains 1- 16 Ounce Jar of Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread Contains 90% Peanuts
Made with just five ingredients
Show More

Peter Pan Original Creamy Peanut Butter, no high-fructose corn syrup, Pack of 12

Peter Pan
1.0188 Pounds

Ratings for Peter Pan (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Swupt -

Features

Contains twelve 16.3-ounce jars of Peter Pan Original Creamy Peanut Butter

Skippy New Ceamy Peanut Butter Spread On-the-Go 8 Mini Pouches, 1 Pack (Creamy)

SKIPPY

Ratings for SKIPPY (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Sebago Foods 112
Caicos 1,286
Spicy Products LLC 4,099
A-Z Best Deal 989

Organic Creamy Peanut Butter 3 - 28 Oz Jars

Kirkland Signature

Ratings for Kirkland Signature (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
TheNewMall 190
ShippedFast 120
Top 20

Kroger Creamy Peanut Butter 16 oz (2 pack)

Kroger

Ratings for Kroger (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Archetype Stores -
Sweet_Southern_Seller -
dreamshoppingland -

Skippy Peanut Butter, Creamy, 28 oz

SKIPPY
10856
3.4 x 3.5 x 5.5 Inches
1.75 Pounds

Ratings for SKIPPY (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

Fuel The Fun
As Always No Trans Fat Per Serving
Show More
Top 22

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounce, 1 Pound (Pack of 1)

Happy Belly
4.86 x 2.94 x 4.86 Inches
1.0575 Pounds

Ratings for Happy Belly (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -

Features

One 16-ounce jar of creamy peanut butter
Packaging might vary
Show More

Good Good Creamy Peanut Butter Keto Friendly - Low Calorie, Low Carb & No Added Sugars - Vegan - No Palm Oil or Preservatives

Good Good
0.82 Pounds

Ratings for Good Good (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Good Good Natural Sweetness LLC -

Features

GAME CHANGING PEANUT BUTTER: Providing the rich essence of a true peanut butter by definition. Made with 91.2% carefully roasted peanuts and containing a whopping 84% of GOOD fats. Delivering a mouth-watering, rich nut butter preserves all the things we all love about peanut butter.
DELICIOUS LOW CALORIE, LOW CARB CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER: This healthy spread is great to be served at breakfast time or as a snack paired with porridge, toast, yogurt or put into a smoothie to keep you feeling energized throughout the day.
Show More
Top 24

Americano No Sugar Added Peanut Butter Creamy, Classic Natural Peanut Butter, 15 Ounce, Sugar Free Peanut Butter Creamy Peanut Butter Natural Peanut Butter No Sugar Peanut Butter (1 Jar (Pack of 1))

Peanut Butter Americano
1.0 Pounds

Ratings for Peanut Butter Americano (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Americano Foods -

Features

🥜 TAKE CARE OF YOUR DIET: We believe that happiness begins with your nutrition, that’s why we are on a mission to spread more happiness! Our classic peanut butter is the perfect ally for anyone worrying about sugar intake since it has no added sugar. Just peanuts and sea salt in this jar! 2 simple ingredients.
🥜 MAKE A HEALTHY SNACKING CHOICE: If your kid is a hard nut to crack and you are having a hard time convincing them to choose the right snack, then you don’t have to sacrifice taste for nutritional value. Treat your kids to a delicious PB cookie, celery sticks dipped in creamy peanut butter or a protein-packed smoothie with peanut butter.
Show More
Top 25

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter Creamy 2 pack 2 pack 3 Pound (Pack of 2)

Skippy Creamy
3.0 Pounds

Ratings for Skippy Creamy (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
IZH STORE LLC -

Features

It's the cream-of-the-crop when it comes to peanut butter.
Skippy Creamy is made from only the freshest peanuts and packed with great peanutty taste.
Show More

Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter U.S. Valencia Peanuts 28 Ounce Each Jar 2 Pack

butter
3.5 Pounds

Ratings for butter (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
ELDENI -
Alpha Crate -

Features

ORGANIC Creamy Peanut Butter
DRY ROASTED
Show More
Top 27

Adams No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

Adam's
051500750353
3.2 x 3.2 x 4.8 Inches
1.55 Pounds

Ratings for Adam's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Greenwald Brands 3,979

Features

0g Trans Fat per Serving
Kosher
Show More

Once Again Natural, Creamy Peanut Butter, 16oz - Salt Free, Unsweetened - Gluten Free Certified, Vegan, Kosher, Non-GMO Verified - Glass Jar (1 Pack)

Once Again

Ratings for Once Again (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Galactic Shop 27
TheNewMall 190

Features

CREAMY PEANUT BUTTER || 16 oz deliciously creamy, natural peanut butter. Our peanut butter is made by roasting and grinding blanched, dry roasted peanuts until they are wonderfully creamy. Contains Peanuts. Produced in a Peanut-only facility
SALT FREE, UNSWEETENED || This product has just one ingredient - peanuts!
Show More

REESE'S Creamy Peanut Butter, 18 oz - Pack of 4

Reese's
4.5 Pounds

Ratings for Reese's (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Kensington Valley Trading 504
RogueDeals34 -
Hemzstores -

Features

Pack of 4 jars
1 jar is 18 oz (1 lb 2 oz) 510 g
Show More

Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, 28 Ounces, Contains 90% Peanuts

Jif
12196
3.5 x 3.5 x 5.7 Inches
1.75 Pounds

Ratings for Jif (CPR Score)

Seller CPR Rank Amazon Fulfilled Prime Free Shipping
Amazon.com -
Woody's World 9,896
US PRIME -

Features

Contains 1 (one) 28 ounce jar of Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread
7g protein (7% DV) per serving (See Nutrition Information For Fat And Saturated Fat Content)
Show More

Top 10 Creamy Peanut Butter - Verified to Buy (Mar. 2024)

Top 10 Creamy Peanut Butter Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by CherryPicks.

  • Jif
  • Justin's
  • SKIPPY
  • Smucker's
  • Peanut Butter Americano
  • Peter Pan
  • Crazy Richard's
  • Tribeca Curations
  • Happy Belly
  • Kirkland Signature

Related Creamy Peanut Butter Guides

For more personalized Creamy Peanut Butter guides, Check those pages,


Top 10 Creamy Peanut Butter Sellers: CPR Seller Rank List

CPR sellers rank is based on CherryPicks-AI bestselling ranking system that helps us analyze each seller's sales trends. The List of top seller ranks is our in-house data, essential for our product ranking to help you make the right shopping choice.

Rank Name Yearly Feedbacks Avg. Ratings
🥇 Galactic Shop 27,961 4.9
🥈 Common Cents Distributors 14,855 4.9
🥉 ShippedFast 14,019 4.9
4 Sebago Foods 10,199 4.9
5 Aserson 8,985 4.9
6 TheNewMall 8,974 4.9
7 Market global 8,281 4.8
8 Kensington Valley Trading 5,345 4.9
9 WhyPayMoreOnline 3,463 4.8
10 A-Z Best Deal 3,127 4.9
View or download top Creamy Peanut Butter seller & rating report
Galactic Shop [27961] Common Cents Distributors [14855] ShippedFast [14019] Sebago Foods [10199] Aserson [8985] TheNewMall [8974] Market global [8281] Kensington Valley Trading [5345] WhyPayMoreOnline [3463] A-Z Best Deal [3127] Galactic Shop 27% Common Cents Distributors 14% ShippedFast 13% Sebago Foods 10% Aserson 9% TheNewMall 9% Market global 8% Kensington Valley Trading 5% WhyPayMoreOnline 3% A-Z Best Deal 3%

[Get] Creamy Peanut Butter Deals (✅Exclusively for Prime)

What does "Amazon Fulfilled" Mean?

Amazon Fulfilled refers to products handled by Amazon's logistics, which indicates that the product is stored, packed, and shipped by Amazon from one of its fulfillment centers.

When you order a product that is "Amazon Fulfilled," Amazon takes care of the storage, packing, shipping, and customer service for that product. This often ensures quicker delivery and better customer service compared to products that are not fulfilled by Amazon. It also means that the product is eligible for Amazon's return policy.

What does "Prime" Mean?

"Prime" refers to Amazon Prime Member (Join Amazon Prime Now), which indicates eligibility for Prime benefits. When you see "Prime" next to a product on Amazon, This generally means that if you are  an Amazon Prime member, you can get free two-day shipping on that product, and sometimes even same-day or one-day shipping depending on your location.

Prime members also have access to other benefits, including 2-Day ShippingExclusive Member DealsPrime VideoBuy With PrimeAmazon MusicPrime Gaming, and more.

Shop Prime Creamy Peanut Butter Deals

What does "Free Shipping" Mean?

"Free Shipping" means that you will not be charged additional fees for the shipping of that product. However, unlike "Prime," which usually guarantees fast two-day shipping, "Free Shipping" doesn't necessarily mean fast shipping.

Sometimes there might be a minimum purchase requirement to qualify for free shipping if you are not a Prime member. For Prime members, the "Free Shipping" usually refers to the free two-day shipping that is one of the benefits of the Prime membership.


Why Should You Trust Us?

Now hundreds and thousands of Pantry Staples supplies are available on Amazon, Picking the right one is not easy, and that may take a lot of your time, Right? and What is the best Creamy Peanut Butter to buy for new March 2024?

CherryPicks’s Methodology for Evaluating Creamy Peanut Butter

We developed the CherryRatings-AI system to identify and score reviews and the CherryPicks-AI ranking system that uses TensorFlow framework to generate the best list, It will help us evaluate Pantry Staples items that sell on Amazon. The score of items is based on over ten parameters such as analyzing customer review content, product reviewing rating statistics, brand reputation evaluation, comparing product price with features, etc, You can visit How We Rank to learn more in detail.

We collected and analyzed 683 of Creamy Peanut Butter reviews based on our selection criteria. It helped us shortlist the top qualified and rated Creamy Peanut Butter for Pantry Staples, We found that most customers choose Creamy Peanut Butter with an average price of $16.38, and the top brands are Happy Belly, Kirkland Signature, Reese's, SKIPPY, Jif, Peter Pan, Crazy Richard's, Tribeca Curations, Peanut Butter Americano, Once Again, Kroger, Smucker's, Skippy Creamy, Justin's, Good Good, butter And Adam's. 

Then our expert-level editors reviewed all those quality items and selected the top 30 Creamy Peanut Butter for you, We have researched hundreds of sellers and picked the top sellers for Pantry Staples, including Galactic Shop, Common Cents Distributors, ShippedFast, Sebago Foods, Aserson, TheNewMall, Market global, Kensington Valley Trading, WhyPayMoreOnline, A-Z Best Deal, Caicos And Affordable OTC. The Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 Ounces (Pack of 4) are available for purchase right now, and The seller of #1 rank product has received honest feedback from 682 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.

We've helped a lot of satisfied users get the right Grocery & Gourmet Food product based on their needs, and save lots of time for them to pick Creamy Peanut Butter to buy.


Written By Yesenia D. Garner

Yesenia has a thing for groceries and gourmet foods and with her, you can discover a lot about groceries you didn't know of before. Yesenia pays attention to details and can be termed as a perfectionist to the core. She writes on groceries and food in general here.