Best Mattress Toppers (April 2024) - Rated by CherryPicks' Experts

How We Picked The Best Mattress Toppers

According to research, 85% of people have found mattress toppers to be very effective, but surprisingly enough, not many people are bothered to invest in one. Our experts did comprehensive hands-on testing and verified customer reviews on different mattress toppers in the market to determine the best ones just for you. We gathered as much information as we possibly could to help you make an informed decision. We are passionate about giving our customers the right to an incredible sleeping experience because we know quality sleep enhances all aspects of life. With so many options available, how did we narrow it down?

Value

We placed our focus on the products that offer the most value. This is to say that they are neither the cheapest nor the most expensive, but they offer great quality for their price. We are always after high-quality products that offer a reasonable price.

Material Quality

The quality of the materials used in the toppers played a huge role in our decision-making. We looked at manufacturer specifications, materials certifications, and top grade material sources to ensure that you have the best of everything. We went through customer reviews to gauge the build and craftsmanship quality of the toppers.

Sleeping Positions

Different mattress toppers are crafted for different sleeping positions. Some are created for more than one sleeping position, so we considered this and reviewed toppers that cover all bases.

Cooling

No one wants to have a hot and stuffy sleeping experience, which is why we factored in the cooling effect in mattress toppers. Cooling properties vary in different toppers, and it all came down to the ultimate comfort the topper will offer you.

Customer Reviews

We went through real customer reviews to get first-hand information from people who have actually tried the toppers for a while. Reviews expanded our data, and allowed us to view these toppers from a larger angle.

Mattress Topper Or Mattress Pad: What’s The Difference?

The Most Compelling Reasons Why You Need a Mattress Topper

They are cheaper compared to replacing a mattress

If your mattress has seen its better days and it is no longer as comfortable as it used to be, you are probably thinking about replacing it. However, getting a new mattress can be quite expensive and there is a possibility you have been postponing the purchase. Fortunately, you don't actually need to replace a mattress. A mattress topper is a perfect way to enhance that mattress and make sleeping appealing to you than it already is, for a fraction of the price.

Additional comfort

Even if your current mattress is already as comfortable as it should be, a mattress topper is still a great addition because it will offer you added comfort. Mattress toppers come in different materials, and you can easily get a luxurious feel at a very affordable price.

Additional Mattress Protection

In all honesty, most mattresses don't come cheap, and you probably want yours to last. A mattress topper offers an additional level of protection that will extend the life of your mattress. Of course, you can always get a mattress protector, but you will miss out on the benefits that come with a mattress topper.

Pain relief for people with back and neck issues

If you have been suffering from back and neck pains, the right mattress topper can help you get relief. For instance, if you purchase a memory foam topper, you will not only get an incredible level of support, but you will be able to correct your sleeping posture. if you're looking to relieve pain, it is very important you get the right mattress topper that will be effective specifically for you.

Motion isolation

If you sleep with a partner and one of you turns to tosses during the night, the movements could bother the other partner and prevent them from getting the sleep they deserve. A mattress topper will eliminate this problem by absorbing the movements. Both partners will have their own personal space and won't have to bother the other when getting in and out of bed.

For more personalized Mattress Toppers guides to match for your different needs, check out the following pages,

Other Things You Need to Know About Mattress Toppers

Mattress toppers come in varying materials, thicknesses and sizes, and finding the right one will highly depend on your presences, needs, and sleeping habits. First, the topper needs to compliment your current mattress, and it needs to be of the right depth in order to benefit you. The topper you choose needs to increase both the comfort and longevity of your mattress.

To ensure you make the perfect purchase that suits your personal needs, it is very important that you consider the factors below.

In what position do you sleep in? Back, stomach, side or a combination of two? Different mattress toppers are designed for different sleeping positions, so this will help you narrow down the choices.

Side Sleepers

Side sleepers require a firm mattress because a lot of pressure goes into their shoulders and hips, which could strain the spine. It is advisable to have a soft topper that contours to the body and allows it to sink a little. Sinking relieves pressure points, so a soft and medium firm mattress topper suits side sleepers.

Back Pain, and Back Sleepers

Most people believe that extra firm toppers are best suited for back sleepers. On the contrary, a study conducted by the US National Library of Medicine shows that medium firmness offers optimum comfort for back sleepers. This level of firmness is also the best for lower back pain relief. The topper needs to be thick enough to offer support, but not too thick to cause strain.

Stomach Sleepers

Sleeping on your stomach puts a strain on your neck and back, and once your hips sag in your mattress, it misaligns your spine. Stomach sleepers need to be as comfortable as possible with the right amount of support, especially for their necks. Soft or plush mattress toppers are the best option for stomach sleepers because they support the neck and spine without compromising on the comfort.

Mattress Topper Material

Mattress toppers come in different materials, all of which offer different benefits. Cotton, for instance, is very breathable, machine washable, and hypoallergenic, but not as durable as other materials. Memory foam, on the other hand, offers a specific body contour, making it one of the most comfortable materials, and latex is not only comfortable, but eco-friendly, hypoallergenic, and extremely durable. However, toppers made from these materials are very expensive.

Your Weight

Your weight is an indispensable factor that you cannot forget to factor in. Consider if you have a large or small body frame. Depending on your weight, your current mattress needs to have enough density to support a topper.

Size and Firmness of Your Current Mattress

A mattress topper sits right on top of the mattress and you need to select a topper based on the firmness of that mattress. Is your mattress firm, medium-firm, soft, or ultra soft? The size of your bed and mattress should also factor in, because toppers come in different sizes, going from king, to queen, full, and twin sizes.

Pain Relief, Support, and Firmness

Are you getting a mattress topper to relieve pain from your back, neck, and joints? Or are you just looking to make your mattress more comfortable? Your answer to these questions will determine what category of mattress topper you should look at. If you need support for your limbs, latex and foam are great options because they hug the body and support its natural posture.

[su_box title="Firmness levels explained" style="soft" box_color="#33c1c8" radius="11"]

Ultra Firm- On a scale of 1 to 10, ultra firm toppers stand at 9. Toppers with this level of firmness offer great support with little to no cushioning. Most ultra firm mattress toppers are constructed with ultra-high density latex, foam, or gel, and they are the thickest in the market.

The firm- These toppers fall under 7 to 8 firmness level and they offer incredible support as well. However, they have more cushioning than ultra firm toppers. This firmness level is optimum for back sleepers, although some side sleepers could use it too.

Medium Firm- This is the middle ground and it falls under 4.5 to 6 on the firmness scale. This level is superb for side sleepers because it offers support in the areas that need it most by contouring the body. Most materials can achieve this level of firmness so you have a wider scope of choice than firm sleepers.

Soft- This level is best suited for people looking for more comfort than support. Soft mattress toppers offer very little support, but optimum levels of comfort and they are perfect for side sleepers. They fall under 3 to 4 on the firmness scale.

Plush- Typically, plush mattress toppers are made with down, and they contour to the body, offering a luxurious sleeping experience. However, these are not for people who suffer from some kind of pain and in need of support. These toppers fall under 1.5 to 2 on the firmness scale.

Ultra Plush- This level offers the softest, cloud-like experience and it suitable for people looking for comfort and luxury instead of support. If you own a firm mattress and want to have a cushioning experience, this would do you justice. On a firmness scale, ultra plush mattress toppers would fall under 1.5 max.

Body Heat

Certain mattress topper materials, such as latex and memory foam are so much better at retaining body heat. The denser and thicker a topper is, the hotter it will feel. On the other hand, wool and feather toppers are good any time of year because they alleviate heat during hot seasons and offer warmth during cold seasons. The external material of the topper also plays a huge role depending on whether it absorbs sweat or not.

Moving and Cleaning Ease

Consider the weight of the topper, and how hard, or easy it will be to move and clean. Different materials come with pros and cons and you will find that while cotton, egg crate, feathers and down are very easy to move unlike foam and latex, they are also harder to clean.

Warranty

On average, most toppers come with a 2-3 year warranty, but you will find some manufacturers, such as the Sleep Innovations offering up to 10 years.

Price

The price of mattress toppers varies greatly and it could go as low as a few dollars to several thousand dollars. High price does not necessarily mean a better mattress topper. You must consider everything that will suit you and then choose the toppers that fall in your budget. Even though price does matter, it should not be a determining factor.

Alleviating Movement

Memory foam and latex toppers offer incredible motion transfer so that people who sleep together don’t disturb each other when turning, or getting out of bed. If you don’t like it when your partner keeps moving around, these materials are the best solution.

Allergies

People who are sensitive to allergies need to have materials that protect them. Some toppers are more resistant to mildew, mites, mold, or even bedbugs than others are. Hypoallergenic and 100% natural mattress toppers are designed for people who would be sensitive to other materials.

Density and Thickness

Mattress topper thickness ranges from 2 to 8 inches. Thicker toppers are best for side sleepers, people who weigh more or those looking to revitalize an older mattress. When it comes to thickness, latex and memory foam have it better. The density of a topper also determines the support you get.

Eco-Friendliness

If you are looking to get an eco-friendly mattress topper, you can get materials such as bamboo or natural latex, which come free of toxic materials.

Cooling Factor

Some mattress toppers come with a ventilation capability, which ensures a consistent airflow. With these toppers, your sleeping temperature will be regulated all night through.

Cover

Some mattress toppers are sold with a cover included while others are sold separately. Covers are beneficial because most of them are made using natural materials such as 100% cotton, or bamboo fabric, and quilted into attractive patterns. They are great at holding two layers of a topper together, and they protect it from dirt. Covers are easily washable compared to the toppers themselves so they do come in handy.

Top 10 Mattress Toppers Sellers: CPR Seller Rank List

CPR sellers rank is based on CherryPicks-AI bestselling ranking system that helps us analyze each seller's sales trends. The List of top seller ranks is our in-house data, essential for our product ranking to help you make the right shopping choice.